Showing posts with label movie vs. book. Show all posts
Showing posts with label movie vs. book. Show all posts

Thursday, April 9, 2026

What do you wish for?

Today (April 9th 2026) is National Unicorn Day.  I like unicorn stories.  Especially the ones where the unicorns are not passive gentle creatures.  Although those are good too.  And probably the ones you want if you are sharing them with children.




Thelma the Unicorn by Aaron Blabey


Thelma is a miniature horse who wants to be a unicorn.  One day she gets her wish (sort of).  But her wish doesn't turn out the way she thought it would.


Thelma worries that she is not special, and believes that she is not good enough the way she is.  Which is a feeling people of all ages can relate to.  When she gets her wish, and everyone thinks she's a unicorn, she finds it comes with unforeseen consequences.  Thelma the Unicorn is a story about being happy being yourself.  I think the illustrations are funny.  I love her donkey best friend.  The rhyming words are fun to read.  It is fun for the adult reading it and the children being read to. 




Thelma the Unicorn starring Brittany Howard


When a freak accident turns Thelma the mini horse into Thelma the Unicorn she finds overnight fame.  Thelma's life changes in a instant.  But is this new life what Thelma really wants?


I found this movie entertaining.  I like the animation.  There were impossible things happening, a narwhale always out of the water, talking animals interacting with people and other things but none of it was an issue for me.  It has a nice theme of being yourself and not forgetting the people who like you for who you are.  I liked Thelma's donkey friends.  Unfortunately Thelma was less easy to like.  And since she is the main character that was an issue for me.  Some of her issues I could relate to but I found it hard to connect with her so the heartwarming parts were not as heartwarming for me.  I'm glad I watched it.  It was fun.  But it is not a movie I would go back and watch over and over again.





As with most book and movie comparisons I liked the book better here.  I watched the movie first so I think I had a less dramatic reaction to the movie than other people who loved the book before the movie.  But I still side with the book.  I know that it is a picture book being turned into a movie so things had to be added.  But the whole rivalry between Thelma and the Narwhale took up too much of the story.  And Thelma was just much more likeable in the book.  I also feel something was lost in the movie when Thelma didn't decide on her own to stop pretending.  She was kind of forced to give it up in the movie and that made it less impactful.  Both are worth a look but I think the book is worth owning while the movie I would suggest you just borrow.

Sunday, October 19, 2025

Be Careful What You Wish For

 The Great Gilly Hopkins by Katherine Paterson


Gilly has been bounced from foster home to foster home.  She does not like any of them and makes it as hard as possible on the foster parents who look after her.  She is tough, smart and difficult.  And she always has a plan.  But she is about to find out that plans don't always have the results you intend.


I don't think anyone who has ever read this book liked Gilly at the beginning.  There isn't much to like.  She is rude, aggressive and a racist.  And no matter how much compassion people have for how hard her life has been, she is more than most people can handle.  Then she meets Trotter and things, and Gilly, start to change.  I like how the new people in Gilly's life relate to her, with understanding but also with grit.  The characters are as complicated as the situations they find themselves in.  Nothing is glossed over and problems are not made to look easy or trite.  The progression Gilly goes through, and how people's attitudes toward her (including the reader) change is a nice, slow, believable transition.  By the end of the book many of the characters have changed and learned something from each other.  Gilly learns some things too late and realizes some things you can't take back.  The ending is both hopeful and heartbreaking.  I enjoyed this sometimes funny, not always happy, but heartfelt and real book.



3-tggh-1-cargo_700.jpg
 The Great Gilly Hopkins starring Sophie Nelisse and Kathy Bates


Gilly Hopkins does not like any of the foster homes she has been in and she makes it as difficult as she can for all of them.  She lives in hope of her mother coming to get her and having a real family.  Then she meets Trotter and realizes she might have the wrong idea about some things.


This movie is sometimes funny, sometimes heartbreaking, sometimes heartwarming, but always entertaining.  The story of Gilly's transformation through the movie is well told, well acted and believable.  All of the characters are interesting and well written.  It moves at a good pace and keeps you interested.  It plays with your emotions in all the right ways.  Love them or hate them (and sometimes it changes as you go) you feel something for these characters.  It is not all fun times but I feel there is hope here.  I am glad I watched it.



I think the movie does a very good job of keeping true to the book.  The characters are all very similar.  There was nothing I felt like the movie was missing or anything too much that they added for no reason.  I think the movie softened the ending some from the book.  I didn't mind the minor changes.  This is one of the very few times when I can not say which one I like better.  I think they are both very good and would recommend both of them.  And which ever one you watch first I don't think you will be disappointed in either.

Saturday, March 8, 2025

Write Your Own Programming



 The Wild Robot by Peter Brown


Roz, the robot, wakes up on an island with no humans, or other robots.  She is not programmed to survive in this world.  And the animal inhabitants think she is a monster.  Both Roz and the animals must adapt to survive.


This book is sad, funny, sweet and hopeful.  Roz may not have emotions but she does evoke them in the reader.  Most people can relate to feeling like they don't belong and can sympathize with Roz and will start to fall in love with her as she tries to fit in.  Most of the animals have big personalities too.  And once Roz learns how to communicate with them you can fall in love with them as well.  It is a heartwarming story as Roz learns to go beyond her programming.  I like how it isn't all Roz changing but the animals are learning and changing too.  It is a lovely story about family, learning to live together and going beyond expectations.  There are some sad moments.  Animals die.  But it is important to include the sad parts of life too.  And I don't think it ever gets too scary for children.  I would recommend this book and plan to read the others in this series.



The Wild Robot starring Lupita Nyong'o


After a shipwreck Roz, the robot, is stranded on an uninhabited island.  As she tries to navigate in a world her programming doesn't cover, where the animals think she is a monster, she also finds herself caring for an orphaned goose.  



The animation is wonderful.  The movie is full of fun moments, there are also sad times but it is mostly hopeful and loving.  It is a lot of fun watching Roz trying to fit in and learn how to survive in this strange world she doesn't understand.  You fall in love with Roz as she learns how to take care of her small goose  charge, and maybe even love him.  It is a beautiful story of learning to go beyond what you are told you are, learning to live and help others, and overcoming differences.  The ending includes some fighting and explosions that might be slightly scary for small children but it is a story about family and learning to live together with others who are not like you that everyone will enjoy. 



Movie vs Book


Once again I am left to wonder why the movie never really follows the book they are based on.  This movie is close to keeping the same themes as the book but how they get there is often different.  As usual I like the book better, but this time it is a closer call.  It was the movie that made me want to read the book, so I did enjoy the movie very much.  The movie is much more about Roz raising the baby goose and all the family problems that come from that.  I like the way the friendship between Roz and the animals is more gradual in the book and it isn't all about one big thing Roz does for the animals.  The movie has added some drama, both between Roz and Brightbill, the goose, and at the big ending.  I don't think the added drama was necessary, but I don't think it took away from the movie either.  I think they are both good and think both are worth your time, and if you like one I think you will like the other. 


Sunday, July 30, 2023

Are You in the Loop?


Tales From the Loop by Simon Stalenhag


In Sweden, in the countryside of  Malaroarna, deep under ground there is the world's largest particle accelerator.  The local people call the compound The Loop.  Strange things happen there.



This book is equal parts strange science fiction tale and art book.  The artwork is beautiful and at a quick glance can be taken for photographs.  But at the same time the images are slightly eerie.  Taken together with the recollections of a man who lived above The Loop it has an unsettling feeling, in the very best way.  It is told in short memories of various things that happened in the area. At the end you are left not knowing if the childhood was happy or scary, or if The Loop was a power for good or not.  I really enjoyed it and plan to look for more work by Stalenhag.



 Tales From the Loop starring Daniel Zolghadri


Under the townspeople's feet is a machine used to explore the mysteries of the universe.  Above the ground the townspeople experience many strange and unexplainable events.



This is an eight episode mini-series.  The cast of characters stays the same throughout the series, but each episode focuses on a different odd incident.  It is a science fiction series that actually takes place in the past.  Which, I think, gives it an interesting feel.  Like all these things are out there right now and we just don't know about it.  The stories are not scary exactly.  They are more creepy and unsettling. Even though they all revolve around The Loop, they all have different, interesting concepts that make you come back for more.  This was a very entertaining series that made me wish there were more episodes.  


Series vs. Book:

There were things in the book that you do not see in the series but there are also things in the series that you do not see in the book.  I think the series does a really good job of keeping the eerie feeling of the book.  Many of the images in the series are exactly the same as the art in the book.  Although there are some big differences between the two, I think the series did a really good job of bringing the book to the screen.  This is a rare occasion where I can't say which one I liked better.  I enjoyed them both.  I will read more books by Zolghadri, and if there is a second season (which I hear there will be) I will definitely watch it.  

Thursday, April 27, 2023

Follow the Elephant



The Magician's Elephant by Kate DiCamillo


Peter was told that his baby sister died at birth, but what if she didn't?  When a fortuneteller tells him she is still alive and an elephant will show him the way to her what will Peter do?  What elephant?  How will an elephant show him the way?  But Peter has hope and determination and sets out to find his sister.



This is a sweet story of hope, belief, family and forgiveness.  DiCamillo sets up a rich setting and develops characters with depth.  Peter's world starts out rather bleak and dark.  And then the elephant appears, literally by magic.   And somehow this event sends ripples through the town, touching everyone.  It is a beautiful story as hope, and wonder, and love start to change the dark lives of the people of the town.  The ending is a little predictable, but it is still wonderful to read.  There are a few dark moments in the story but ultimately it is about the power of family, hope, wonder, friendship, and forgiveness.






The Magician's Elephant starring Noah Jupe


Peter, an orphan being raised by a soldier, has always believed that his baby sister had died.  But when a fortuneteller tells him she is still alive he is determined to find her.  He is told to 'follow the elephant'.  And his quest changes his life and the lives of those around him in unexpected ways.



In a once magical town, hope has disappeared along with the sun.  But then a desperate magician makes an elephant appear and things start to change.  It is fun to watch the town slowly start to come back to life, mostly in the background so make sure to watch, as Peter goes on his quest to find his sister.  There are a wide cast of characters that the audience becomes attached to.  And you feel for Peter as everything seems to want to stop him in his search.  It's fun to watch the characters, some of whom start out sad and lost, change and grow through the story.  It is a fun, beautiful, emotional story about the power of love, empathy, family, and forgiveness.  And it shows you what can happen if you dare to ask the question, "But what if?".  



The movie stays close to the basic story of the book.  There are lots of moments that you will recognize from one to the other.  But there are lots of differences too.  Starting with how the soldier raising Peter got him to how Peter gets the elephant.  Some things are vastly different.  There are new characters in the movie that don't exist in the book.  I, personally, do not like the addition of the king.  He might have been put in as some comic relief (it can get a little dark at times) but I don't think his goofy character fits the feel of the story.  And the added drama from the way Peter gets to the elephant is probably considered important in a movie but was unnecessary in the book.  I liked both of them but, if forced to choose, I would say the slightly simpler, more concise story of the book has a slight edge.


Friday, March 3, 2023

There's What in the Attic?


The House on East 88th Street and Lyle, Lyle Crocodile by Bernard Waber

A family moves into a new house only to find that a crocodile already lives there.


So, the idea of a crocodile living with a family is a fun idea.  But I'm not sure why these stories became so popular.  I can get over the fact that people are happy for their children to be playing with a crocodile, it is fiction after all.  But he is living in a house all by himself and no one wonders how he is surviving.  And the man who got Lyle into show business is a terrible person.  Am I supposed to hate him?  Because I do.  I don't even think Lyle likes him that much.  But then he acts like they are good friends.  So that relationship confused me.  Maybe I am just too cynical.  Maybe a more light hearted person (like a child) would be able to overlook all the odd bits that bothered me.  I won't be reading the rest of the books in the series.  But if you want to try them make sure you start with The House on East 88th Street, that is the first one and some of the stuff in Lyle, Lyle Crocodile I found confusing until I went back to the beginning.



Lyle, Lyle Crocodile starring Winslow Fegley and Javier Bardem

A family moves into a new house only to find that a singing crocodile lives in the attic.


Lyle is cute.  And you do warm up to him just like the family he lives with does.  It's a fun story with a villain who is suitably scummy and a nice heart warning ending.  But why can Lyle sing but not talk?  That bothers me.  Just have a talking crocodile, or not.  I do like the relationship Lyle has with the pampered cat next door.  It is fun to watch and I think kids with like it.  But for me it is just average.



How does the movie compare to the book?  A lot of the same elements and scenarios show up in both.  And the story is pretty much the same story, with slight variations.  The biggest difference is that Lyle can sing in the movie but not the books.  But in the books Lyle is a performer so it isn't totally off base.  I think the book to movie transition was a good one.   I think I liked the movie slightly better because it seemed to have a little more explanation of how everything came about.  (Not how Lyle came to be able to sing, unfortunately.  But you can't have everything.)   And the entertainer who got Lyle into show business was more firmly put in the villain category so I didn't have to wonder about that relationship.  I think the movie is worth a look but I wouldn't recommend the books.

Thursday, June 23, 2022

A Not So Spooky Phantom

 

The Phantom Tollbooth by Norton Juster


(from the back of the book)

For Milo, everything's a bore.  When a tollbooth mysteriously appears in his room, he drives through only because he's got nothing better to do.  But on the other side, things seem different.  Milo visits the Island of Conclusions (you get there by jumping), learns about time from a ticking watchdog named Tock, and even embarks on a quest to rescue Rhyme and Reason!  Somewhere along the way, Milo realizes something astonishing.  Life is far from dull.  In fact, it's exciting beyond this wildest dreams...


Milo is bored.  With everything.  But when he goes through the phantom tollbooth and finds himself in a whole new world things start looking up.  He meets a watchdog, names Tock, who is horrified when Milo says he wants to kill some time.  It is bad enough wasting it, but killing it?  And so it goes.  He meets a Spelling Bee who is an actual bee, gets to the Land of Conclusions by jumping, makes a wagon move by staying silent because it 'goes without saying'.  The book is full of word play and puns.  I loved it, but I also think I liked it more as an adult than I would have as a child.  I think some of the wordplay would be lost on young children.  That doesn't mean it wouldn't be fun for children.  Milo goes on an adventure and meets all sorts of interesting characters that I think would hold a child's interest.  And our hero, Milo, learns some things along the way.  He is given some bits of wisdom like 'the only thing  you can do easily is be wrong, and it is hardly worth the effort', and 'so many things are possible just as long as you don't know they're impossible',  He also realizes that all the learning that he didn't see the point of before comes in handy along the way.  It does tend to amble a bit.  At times it seems like Milo is going nowhere but I think the humor and wit of the story make all the stops along the way to rescue Rhyme and Reason worth it.  I think it is a fun adventure for young and old alike.




The Phantom Tollbooth starring Butch Patrick


One day Milo comes home to find a mysterious gift.  It is a tollbooth.  And since he is bored he decides to drive through it.  It takes him to a strange new world where he finds all sorts of adventures.



The movie starts out as live action, but as soon as Milo goes through the tollbooth he turns into a cartoon.  (He notices this and still goes through.  I don't think I've ever been that bored.)  He goes to all sorts of strange lands and meets all sorts of interesting characters.  He becomes friends with a watchdog named Tock, meets a which (not a witch), is forced to eat his words (literally), and goes on a mission to save Rhyme and Reason.  Milo goes on a grand tour of this new world realizing that all the things he was forced to learn, that he thought pointless before, are actually useful and maybe the world is not as boring as he thought.  By today's standards it is probably on the slow side.  It is full of wordplay and puns.  Which are fun and witty.  But it is based on dialog and there is some, but not much, action.  I think kids will like the crazy characters and fun concept and adults will appreciate the wit and wordplay.



Movie vs Book -


I liked the book and the book is a lot of wordplay and I think a lot of that works better in print than it does in a movie.  So I think the book comes out on top for me.  But I did like the movie as well.  And I was not disappointed like I often am by movie versions of books I like.  There are differences of course.  Some of the encounters Milo has in the book aren't in the movie and that changes the course of events slightly along the way.  And the ending, for some reason, is changed up more than I thought was necessary but I thought the movie stayed true to the spirit of the book.  And if you liked the book I think you will like the movie too (and vice versa).



Monday, April 25, 2022

Penguins Galore!

 Today (April 25th) is World Penguin Day!

(Not to be confused with National Penguin Day Which is in January.)



Everyone loves penguins.  They are cute and silly and just watching them waddle around makes you laugh.  I like penguins too.  But I don't think I would want them as a pet.  Unlike Mr. Popper.  Who welcomes them into his home.  That might be a fun concept for a book and a movie but I don't think it would be very funny in real life.  Besides, I think it would be illegal.


But that's why we love fiction.  Rules do not apply.



Mr. Popper's Penguins by Richard and Florence Atwater


Mr. Popper is obsessed with the polar regions.  One day, in response to a letter he wrote to an artic explorer, he receives a penguin in the mail.


It's silly and goofy and all sorts of impossible things happen, starting with a penguin being sent in the mail from the Antarctic.  It is a kind of fantasy book since none of this could happen in the real world so don't count on this book for penguin facts.  But the idea of having a penguin (and then lots of penguins) in the house is a fun one.  And I think most kids (and some adults) would find it funny - the penguins living in the refrigerator, sliding down the stairs on their bellies, and riding the bus.  My biggest criticism of the book is Mr. Popper.  After he gets the penguin he starts spending all the family money on it, even after his wife mentioned her worries about being able to afford food.  Mr. Popper treated the penguin like it was more important than his family and I could not forgive him for that.  Although a child would probably not take it all so seriously and just enjoy the silly antics on the penguins and Mr. Popper alike.




Mr. Popper's Penguins starring Jim Carey


Mr. Popper inherits a penguin and it turns his life upside down.


Carey was a perfect pick because he does the silly, goofy thing so well.  And this movie is definitely silly and goofy.  Like the book, it is a fantasy in so far as none of this stuff could actually happen.  But it is fun and there were moments that made me chuckle.  I think penguins in the city are just naturally funny and watching them waddle around outside of their natural habitat will amuse young and old alike.  It is a good family film that turns out to be more about Mr. Popper's family than his penguins.  


Movie vs. Book


I didn't like either Mr. Popper but in the movie he was able to redeem himself to some degree.  Both were full of things that could never happen and sometimes goes to eyeroll levels.  But it's kids fiction so it is forgivable.  Why Mr. Popper comes to have the penguins, and his reactions to the penguins completely different.  They share some elements but they are not really the same story.  Is one better than the other?  Apple and oranges.  I think I would have to say I personally enjoyed the movie more.  But the book is a simpler, less complicated story with less real world problems.  Which does have a certain appeal.








Tuesday, July 26, 2016

Tuesday With Morrie Movie vs Book

Tuesdays with Morrie by Mitch Albom
Tuesdays with Morrie with Hank Azaria and Jack Lemmon

Both the book and the movie are about a journalist that reconnects with one of his former college professors when he hears that his professor is dying.
Morrie, the professor, shares the insights that he has learned as the disease that will eventually take his life ravishes his body.  And these conversations have a profound impact on his former student, Mitch.


The book and the movie follow very similar lines and there are times when the wording is exactly the same.  But there were differences.  In the book (and I’m assuming, real life) Mitch is married, but for some reason in the movie he isn’t.  In the movie he has a girlfriend and the relationship between them takes up much more of the movie than it does of the book.  In fact there is a lot more in the movie that involves Mitch when he isn’t with Morrie.  Almost the entire book takes place in Morrie’s home, you don’t get to see much of Mitch’s life at all.  I don’t know if they just added things from life to make it more complete or added made up things to make it more dramatic, but you get to see more of his work and home life.

I wasn’t that big of a fan of the book because I thought, despite the very personal nature of the story, that it was reduced to a bunch of pithy sayings.  Which, I admit, mean more coming from someone who has to actually live them, but at times it started to feel like a bunch of clichés strung together and it became trite.  Which is sad because I’m sure Morrie’s life was anything but trite.  And I don’t know how you can tell such a personal, emotional tale and still leave me feeling like I don’t know the people involved.  But that was how the book made me feel.  So it was nice that the movie added more of the people’s lives.  I found it easier to connect to the people because I felt I knew them better.  So I think the movie edges the book out a little for me.  But the movie still has some of the slightly preachy, slightly condescending feel the book had so I wasn’t the biggest fan of the movie either.

Tuesday, July 10, 2012

Last Unicorn Movie vs. Book


The Last Unicorn by Peter Beagle
The Last Unicorn with Alan Arkin and Jeff Bridges

A unicorn comes to believe that she is the last unicorn in the world and sets out to see if she can find any others.

In broad strokes the story in the movie and the book are the same.
The unicorn sets out on a journey to find other unicorns.  She meets up with Schmendrick the magician and Molly Grue and heads toward King Haggard’s castle to solve the mystery of the missing unicorns.  But the book is deeper somehow.  It is also infinitely sadder.  Schmendrick is a bit of a clown in the movie, when his tricks go wrong it’s funny but in the book he is not a character that can be laughed at, he is to be pitied.  There is a dark gloomy feeling to the entire book that doesn’t completely come across in the movie and I think it loses something.  As with most book to movie conversions parts were cut for the movie.  There is a whole cursed town in the book that doesn’t show up in the movie.  There are a few other things that don’t show up too but mostly things that the story could work around, it still works without them.  The cut that really makes a difference is the time table.  Things happen more quickly in the movie.  The slow loss of hope, the creeping despair is lost in the movie and it fails to have the same impact.  The movie was okay but the book was great.  

Sunday, March 25, 2012

Skellig Book vs. Movie

Skellig by David Almond
Skellig: The Owl Man with Tim Roth



Michael moves into a new home with his parents and newborn sister. He finds a man in the run down garage that is not quite a man. And he and his friend Mina befriend this incredible being and all their lives are changed forever.

The book is a deceptively simple story about a boy who is both jealous of and worried about his baby sister who has been sick since the day she was born. There is a subtle magic and fantasy to the story that adds a nice twist to the traditional coming of age tale of a boy in a new home, with a new sister and all the other changes in his life. And it also shows what friendship and love can do in people’s lives.

The movie is more dramatic. It seems that everything is done bigger. Starting with small things like how rude Skellig was to begin with to a big dramatic flying scene. Everyone’s reactions are bigger. There’s more yelling between the characters. The magic is more obvious. All these things can be expected to try to make the movie more entertaining but it takes some of the simplicity that I liked in the book away.

Mina is a bit of a stuck up brat in both the book and movie but she seems less likeable in the movie.

One of Michael’s friends is also rather unlikeable. He made fun of Michael a bit in the book too. But at least in the book you could see why they were friends to begin with but it was hard to see it in the movie.

The stories are very similar and most of the changes can be forgiven for the sake of trying to make a dramatic movie but I like the way the book is a smaller, softer, subtler story where the power of it kind of sneaks up on you and surprises you.

Thursday, June 9, 2011

Blood and Chocolate Movie vs. Book

Blood and Chocolate by Annette Curtis Klause
Blood and Chocolate with Agnes Bruckner and Hugh Dancy

The book is about a family of werewolves. They have been forced to flee from their home and find a new one. Vivian, our hero, is trying to find her own way in a pack dynamic that expects certain things from her that she is not sure she wants for herself. She has a softer side that she does not see in the pack and looks to the humans to find. The pack looks for leadership and safety while trying to leave behind a bloody mistake.

The movie is not about that at all. Vivian does fall in love with a human but there is not much the same after that. She is not even the one to initiate the contact with him or pursue the relationship. Some of the things that she liked about him in the book are missing in him in the movie, his sense of ‘pack’ with his friends, the fact that he is not as rough as the guys in her pack. He has no friends in the movie and he is tougher in a running and fighting sort of way. The relationship between them is less sexually driven in the movie so in some ways seems sweeter but in the process it changes their relationship. The rules of the pack are completely different. There is a leader already and he is a bit of a jerk. And the whole outcome is completely different. So different they are almost opposites. It’s impossible to point out all the things that are different in the movie. They are just not the same story.

For that reason it is hard to say which one I liked better. I think the book is more about Vivian and her personal struggle than it is a straight werewolf story. There is more action in the movie, more fights and chases. The movie is more a physical battle for Vivian than the emotional one that she has in the book. So it depends on what you are looking for. I thought both of them were worth a look, but if you read and love the book don’t expect the same from the movie or you will be disappointed.

Tuesday, April 5, 2011

Coraline Movie vs. Book

Coraline by Neil Gaimen
Coraline with Dakota Fanning

Coraline is a story about a bored girl who discovers a secret door and on the other side finds a twisted copy of her own family and world.


The movie and the book have very similar storylines. There is the door that is sometimes open and sometimes not. There is the skewed version of Coraline’s world on the other side. There is the slow realization that it is not a good place to be. And then there is the battle to save herself and her parents. And everything in both is creepy and eerie. But although the book was a full, complete story with plenty of depth of its own the movie felt compelled to add elements to it. They were not bad exactly, but they were unnecessary and didn’t really add anything to the story so I don’t see the point. The movie adds a boy neighbor and a doll that looks like Coraline. They are both rather important to the movie but not in the book at all. There were a couple of scenes that were made bigger, more theatrical that worked in a movie that could not have been described well in a book. There are other things that got added as well that don’t detract from the story but I would have liked to see the movie stick more closely to the book. The characters are slightly different too. The mother is less just preoccupied and more angry all the time. The man upstairs has been turned into an eccentric gymnast always jumping and swinging instead of just the man upstairs with a mouse circus act. And Coraline doesn’t seem as clever in the movie. She has help she didn’t have in the book and she doesn’t figure certain things out that she does in the book. So I liked some of the characters more in the book. But not by a lot. They were both fun and creepy. The book edges out the movie in my opinion but the movie is good too.

Monday, February 28, 2011

Princess Bride Movie vs. Book

Princess Bride by William Goldman
Princess Bride with Cary Elwes and Robin Wright

I saw the movie first and absolutely loved it. Doesn't everyone? The wonderful characters, the sword fights, the wit and all the things that the grandfather promises too.

And then I read the book. I liked the book. But I didn't love it like I thought I would.

Now I'm going to warn you right now that I'm going to assume that everyone has seen the movie so if you haven't there might be some spoilers in here that you won't want to read. And if you haven't seen the movie I suggest that you do. I, as I mentioned, love it and I haven't run into anyone yet who didn't.

It's obvious that I liked the movie better so I don't see any reason not to mention that right off but I do see how the book could have more appeal to some.

The characters are basically the same. Westly is dashing, Inigo is a great swordsman out for revenge, Fezzik is nice but not so bright, and Vizzinii is out to make a profit and enamored of his own genius. You get more background on all of the characters in the book. They give a brief history of Inigo and Fezzik and how they came to hook up with Fenzini. You get to see Buttercup's home life too. In the book she has parents and you get to see more of a family life for her. So all of the characters don't just show up out of the blue. But everyone is just slightly different. Westly is more condescending to Buttercup, Buttercup is not very smart and seems less devoted to Westly when she gives her reasons for leaving him at the fireswamp. Fezzik was never very smart but it is more evident in the book and he becomes a little less personable. Inigo and Vizzini are very close though.

There are scenes that come word for word from the book. The inconceivable conversation, the iocane powder scene, and some others that were just as much fun in the book as they were in the movie. A lot more happens in characters heads in the book though. When Fezzik is trying to figure out why he can't beat Westly or when Inigo is going on about the Capo Ferro defense and all of that during the duel it is all internal monologue. But I think the dialogue between the characters in these scenes makes them funnier and I missed it in the book.

The friendship between Fezzik and Inigo is explored more in the book and there are more scenes with just the two of them. And I liked those two together.

The ending of the movie is much more fairy-tale than the book. But I think the movie was much more fairy-tale all the way through. I think the movie is funnier and more light hearted than the book. But the book does provide some more information about the characters and doesn't just start with two people in middle of nowhere with no explanation or reason. And I liked Westly and Buttercup in the movie better. But it depends on what you are looking for I guess. I probably would have liked the book more if I had not already seen and loved the movie.

Sunday, January 2, 2011

The Fantastic Mr. Fox Movie vs. Book

The Fantastic Mr. Fox by Roald Dahl
The Fantastic Mr. Fox with George Clooney

The book is about a fox who steals birds from three mean farmers and the attempt of those farmers to get revenge on the fox. The fox is a rather happy go lucky kind of guy who lives with his wife and four children. They are a happy family until all Mr. Fox’s years of stealing catch up to him and he has to outsmart the farmers to save the life of his family and all the creatures that live on his hill. His wife is loving and supportive and doesn’t play much of a role. Neither do his children. Or really any of the other animals for that matter.

The movie has the same basic storyline except Mr. Fox has not been stealing from these farmers for years already. But the movie adds a lot. Mr. Fox now has a nephew and an opossum friend. There is a lot more going on, with the relationships between him, his wife and his son, with his promise to give up stealing, with his worries about where he lives and all of that. All of the characters are more complex in the movie and often had bigger parts to play. Which made them more interesting. (Except for the rat in my opinion who was so ridiculous as to be annoying.) And there is more humor in the movie too.

I didn’t love either of them really. The book was quick to read and the movie enjoyable to watch once but I don’t think I’ll be going back to either. I do think I liked the movie better this time simply because there was more to it. The story and the characters have more depth. There was more character in the characters. You got to know them in a way I don’t think you did in the book. And the story wasn’t all about stealing chickens but was also about Mr. Fox and his family. All of which made the movie hold my attention better than the book.

Tuesday, October 26, 2010

Appaloosa Movie vs Book

Appaloosa by Robert B. Parker
Appaloosa with Ed Harris

Appaloosa is about Virgil Cole and Everett Hitch, two lawmen, who are asked to come to Appaloosa to get rid of Bragg who is taking over the town.

And the movie is about exactly the same thing.

But it is about more than the fight against Bragg, it is also about the kind of men that these two friends are and about their friendship as well. The way the two play off of each other can be hilarious at times but the story has a tragic side too. There is the worry for the heroes when it looks like the bad guy has gotten the upper hand. There is the exasperation at Cole who seems bent on things that are not good for him. There is the genuine caring for these two good guys and their quiet but certain friendship. The villain is slimy, the heroes nice guys the town’s people interesting and the love interest convoluted to say the least. I liked it a lot.

And I can say the same thing about the movie as well. It did a good job of capturing the feel of the book and the characters. Much of the dialogue is taken word for word from the book. There are no scenes when you are wondering where that was in the book. There are no new characters that you have to wonder where they came from (mostly anyway). The witness against Bragg is a different person in the movie than in the book but that is really the only change in cast that you see. There are a few scenes that didn’t make it to the movie. But most of them you really don’t miss. They are things are along the lines of Hitch has a conversation with someone and tells Cole about it later and in the book you see both the original conversation and the one with Cole and in the movie you only see Hitch talking to Cole. And although the scenes do not feel redundant in the book you can surmise enough from the second conversation that you don’t even know anything is missing. In all it is a very faithful book to movie conversion.

I would have a hard time trying to say which I liked better. So I’m going to pronounce this one a tie. I saw the movie first so I had the actors in my head as I read but in this case I was okay with that. If you want to make up your own mind about what people look and sound like than you should obviously read the book first. But I don’t think you will be disappointed in either of them no matter what order you choose.

Thursday, July 8, 2010

The Land That Time Forgot movie vs. book

The Land that Time Forget by Edgar Rice Burroughs
The Land that Time Forgot with Doug McClure

I think the movie was pretty close to the book this time. Most of the major pieces were all the same, how they came to be there, the kinds of people and animals they bumped into, how they planned to get out, how Tyler’s message got out of Caspak, and the ending was even very close. The movie made the German captain much more personable. You could like him in the movie whereas you really couldn’t in the book. The woman was more annoying in the movie. I think they were trying to make her a stronger character by making her a scientist and having her contribute more but I was left to roll my eyes when the native drew stick figures in the dirt and she comes out with ‘what he means is’ and continues to postulate some involved theory of evolution. I just wanted her to shut up. They also were able to figure out more stuff in the movie then they were able to in the first book of the trilogy but nothing they didn’t figure out eventually. Both the book and the movie are good, campy fun. And the annoyance of the woman is balanced out by the fact that I do like the German captain better in the movie. I think this one might be a tie.



The People that Time Forgot by Edgar Rice Burroughs
The People that Time Forgot with Patrick Wayne

They are not even telling the same story. In the movie they head out to find Bowen Tyler, and the woman they meet when they get there is named Ajor but that is the last thing that even resembles the book. Except for the dinosaurs. There are dinosaurs. I can’t even say where it went different from the book because there are no common points of reference. At first I wanted to give the movie the benefit of the doubt, so when they had a whole team of people go in instead of Thomas Billings being there all alone, or when Ajor spoke English, I just chalked it up to those differences that movies always make to make filming easier or to add drama. But then it went widely off base and there was no way to pretend it was even remotely following the book. And as a movie I didn’t even think it was cheesy fun like I had hoped. Again the woman was annoying with her ‘I can do a man’s job’ attitude that always comes off as arrogance instead of confidence. The hero of the sorry tale is a bit of a jerk too. And then when the guys in what looked like samurai armor show up it was too much even for me. It was cheesy to be sure. It just wasn’t fun. And I didn’t like the ending. The book is certainly better and I can’t even say that the movie was okay if you don’t compare it to the book. It isn’t. Don’t bother.

Tuesday, May 25, 2010

The Firm, book vs. movie

The Firm by John Grisham
The Firm with Tom Cruise

The book is about a lawyer, Mitch McDeere, who ends up working for a firm that is majorly corrupt. So is the movie, only, of course, different. As with any longish book that gets turned into a movie things are shortened and left out. The movie leaves off a lot of the beginning of the book when Mitch is getting to know the people and getting involved in the work and his attachment and involvement seem less because of it. It also shortens the time that the firm is talking to him before he takes the job and a few strange things happen that make you wonder why he took the job in the first place whereas in the book the warning signs were less obvious. Everybody’s character is slightly different in the book as well. For the most part it didn’t make too much difference to the plot but in the case of Avery, Mitch’s mentor, they made him a much more sympathetic character and it changed the whole feel of the relationship between him and Mitch and the way that it all played out. Of course, by that time they had changed so much other stuff that a few more things couldn’t have made any difference. There were little things like the fact that the FBI had to tell him things that he worked out for himself in the book and he worked things out for himself things that the FBI had to tell him in the book. And though there were more times in the movie that he was literally running from the bad guys the book was more suspenseful because everything was based on timing. But then there were bigger things too. Abby, Mitch’s wife, ended up playing a different part in the plan, the plan that Mitch comes up with is totally different, and most important, the ending was completely different as well. I thought at first the movie was trying to make the ending work out better for Mitch and Abby, have a slightly happier ending, but Mitch seems more bitter at the end of the movie than he did at the end of the book so I don’t think that was it. In fact, I think the book might have had a happier ending in the sense that the characters were happier. Once again I was left to wonder why the movie changed so much of the book. I understand that some things simply will not work in a movie and that there are time constraints and you want to make a movie more sensational and all of that but it isn’t like they are trying to hind the fact that the story has been done before. It is based on a book. It should be a story we have heard before. I was mad through the entire movie at the things that had been changed. Am I overreacting? Yes. I know I am. I don’t know why this particular book to movie conversion irritated me so much but it did. Maybe it’s because I felt like the story had potential as a movie but the actual movie didn’t cash in on any of it. Maybe I just don’t like Tom Cruise. Or that Gene Hackman (who I do like) had anything to do with this clunker. I don’t know. But watching this just confirmed for me that when I write my best selling novel I’m not going to let anyone turn it into a movie. I don’t want to see my carefully plotted novel ravaged and all my hard work thrown out the window. But since I will never write my novel I will just be indignant for those who have, since they don’t seem to be indignant themselves.

(In case there was any doubt, I'm on the side of the book here.)

Thursday, April 8, 2010

Dead and Buried, movie vs. book

Dead and Buried by Chelsea Quinn Yarbro
Dead and Buried with James Farentino

In Potter’s Bluff people are being killed and it looks like they just might be coming back.

The book is creepy and spooky and a lot of that comes from the fact that things develop slowly and you don’t know what is going on for some time. So many things look normal and there are just little clues for you to follow. The sheriff has time to wonder if the deaths are accidental, to wonder what is going on with his wife. There is time for the tension and mystery to build. Unfortunately there isn’t time for that in the movie. Things happen much more quickly. The tension wasn’t allowed to build and it made it less a creeping terror and made it a little campy. And one of the scenes that I found most frightening in the book, where a couple and their son are being chased, loses some of its impact by being turned into a short chase instead of the running and hiding and moments when you think they are safe. Except for the pace, at first the movie does closely follow the book. You can see all the major events and they happen pretty much the way they did in the book. There are changes to some small things, people die in different ways for instance, and there seemed to be no reason for the changes but they didn’t make too much difference, they just made it more gruesome (maybe that’s the reason I was looking for). And the movie was more gruesome. There are some descriptions of the burned dead bodies in the book but mostly it isn’t a blood and guts horror it is more an eerie kind of horror. Later in the movie there are a few big event changes that I was annoyed about at first but they managed to fit in without much change to the overall plot and outcome. Because you can actually see who is doing what in the movie a few things were more explicit than they were made in the book but they were hinted at in the book so not too much was given away and in the end it just added to the quicker pace of the movie that had already been established. I was glad to see that the ending of the movie was very close to the book and so kept the effect the same. Overall I think the movie was pretty true to the ideas, concepts and feel of the book if not always the exact sequence of events. I think this is a good book to movie conversion but I still find myself on the side of the book. Mostly, I think, because I tend to like the creepy horror, the empty house, spooky sounds, you feel like someone if watching you type stuff over the splashing blood and dismemberment horror. And the book was more the former and the movie more the latter.

Friday, January 29, 2010

'Salem's Lot Movie vs. Books vs. Movie

‘Salem’s Lot by Stephen King
‘Salem’s Lot with David Soul
‘Salem’s Lot with Rob Lowe

In short, the book and both movies are about a small town being taken over by vampires.

In the Rob Lowe movie you can see who all the characters correspond to in the book but they are all very different. Ben’s girlfriend is less innocent and their relationship is less sweet. The doctor is not as nice a man. Ben is not just a little known author but a controversial one. Matt is not as friendly and is critical of Ben. There is never really a friendship between them that you see n the book. The priest is less a man who had a lapse in faith but a believer in redemption and more a lost man. Mark is a trouble kid instead of a quiet outsider. Most of the characters are a lot less likable in the movie. The movie also adds elements that seem unnecessary and, in my opinion, detract from the story. Eva has a past with the vampire. When Ben tells the story of his first trip into the Marsten house he sees so much more than he does in the book, more supernatural things. The ending is completely different in the movie. There are less loose ends left and, partly due to that but also due to the nature of the ending, it is less creepy.

In the David Soul movie a lot of things are cut out or truncated. There is no Dub or dump, there is only one trip to the house instead of two near the end of the book. Some of the characters seem to be melded together. Mark and the priest play much smaller roles. Also Mark is not as strong a character and less believable as some one who would be out hunting vampires. There is no sense of a team among the people who know about the vampires that you get in the book and the other movie. The vampire was reduced to an inarticulate monster. It makes him less insidious and also makes it impossible for the personal threats that the vampire makes in the book. The ending is closer to the book but of course not the same.

In both movies, of course, the descriptive language that is a large part of the book is lost. And things tend to develop more quickly so it is less a creeping evil that can establish itself before anyone is aware. There is also more that is explicitly shown in the movies, people being turned into vampires instead of them getting sick and turning and you just knowing that their vampire friends must have come for them in the night. It leaves less to the imagination.

Since I didn’t like most of the people in the Rob Lowe movie I had trouble enjoying the movie very much. It was alright but nothing spectacular. The David Soul movie I liked better. But that is because I like vampire movies and if you just watch it as a vampire movie and forget that it is based on the book I think it can be a lot of fun. But, as is almost always the case when I read the book and watch the movie, I liked the book best. It is a much more intricate story and a much creepier tale.